Dining about town...Terragusto style
Recently my wife and I were joined by a dear friend, Eric, to dine at a newer Roscoe Village spot, Terragusto. As always, I sought out reviews ere venturing out, and was in this case please to find a number on metromixes website from various readers. Alas, a seeming dichotomy presented itself in those reviews. They either praised the food or cursed the prices. Thankfully, none cursed the food, but only its presumed value. Hoping this was a good sign, we sallied forth.
While on the busy street of Addison, parking was no difficulty, for which I was grateful. The restaurant itself is located in a brickfront locale on a corner, and is as unassuming inside as out. Really, the only indications that this is a restaurant is the sign on the door and the (at the time) unused pasta preparation bar in the front window. Inside, largely unadorned brick walls are the norm, with the cramped but serviceable kitchen visible through the open door and service window. Not only does this add a certain element of interaction with the kitchen's activity, if only in a visual sense, but I'm sure it provides the various prep cooks the chance to NOT go mad from claustrophobia, an issue in kitchens everywhere as it is. Aside from the Pasta prep area, there is the front service bar where the waitstaff waited for walk-ins. The expected register, water station and espresso bar were in evidence, but also a variety of locally prepared italian condiments for sale, and a glass fronted refrigerator case displaying a number of fresh pastas and the raw ingredients for some of the desserts. Visually a little static, but interesting at the same time. The space overall could have crammed more tables in, but only at the cost of privacy and comfort. As we would see later, this is not only a good decision in terms of comfort, but conversation. At capacity, the dull roar of other patrons might have drowned out our own conversation had greater numbers been present. On entering, we were politely asked if we had a reservation. On admitting we did not, a rustle of consternation moved through the staff. Still, they muttered among themselves for a bit before ushering us to the table closest to the door and the resident drink cooler. The lesson was learned; make reservations for this restaurant. Our waiter, David, came over and promptly opened our bottle of wine, (the restaurant is the best sort of BYOB...no corkage fee, and no resentment,) after he had discovered our water preference and delivered it to the table. The description of the menu was cogent and honest. The few points where a detail was forgotten, David stepped away to relearn what he had forgotten rather than skipping over it. A tiresome detail perhaps, but a welcome one. A tight selection of insalatas and antipasti were to start, followed by Primi plates to be consumed individually, and then a selection of secondi plates to be shared. We started with an antipasti selection, largely of italian classics. A hardboiled egg in quarters with a drizzle of olive oil and what seemed to be gremolata was accomanied by a selection of crudites for dipping in an anchovie basil olive oil mix. Sliced sausage and salami sat opposite roasted and thinly sliced squash, with an exquisite buffalo mozzerella in the center. Crostini accompanied it all, and I can admit no complaints. The olive oil was delicious, a rich golden tone with grassy and herbal notes. The mozzerella was exceptional, toothsome and flavorful in a was store bought mozzerella never is. The squash did not thrill, but this admits as much of my own prejudice as the preparation. The anchovy/herb paste in the oil was tremendous, and we had a tendency to use it as a general condiment with any other item atop the available bread.
The polenta that followed was baked and accompanied with squash and tomato, olive oil and basil. The baking gave it a pleasant al dente presentation, while permitting the corn undertones to shine. In accompaniment with the tomato and squash, the sweet and savory notes of the ground corn were evoked in an exquisite fashion. If antipasti is simple by necessity and nature, this dish was the same by design. The harmonious whole was a simple and delicious delight.
Following this, Eric had a salad I did not sample, but claimed it was excellent, with no elucidations.
Our raviolis arrived next, with the secondi plate we had selcted due to arrive halfway through these. Both the Missus and I tried the potato raviolis with pancetta and pine nuts. The pasta was perfect, but the potato stood up well, with a savory roastiness that was further evoked by the toasted pine nuts, and then simultaneously called out and enhanced by the deep flavors and saltiness of the pancetta. Altogether, I felt the salt became a little to dominant, and I personally would have appreciated a little cream to round it out, but as it was it was still incredible, allowing the simplicity of ingredients to interact and shine.
The secondi plate that arrived was a porkchop of generous proportions, simply dressed in salt and roasted in iron. It was perfectly juicy and flavorful, but it didn't really shine until we tried the roasted tomatoes benath it and the complement of polenta nestled like a golden treasure within those. The tomatoes were an unexpected source of sweetness to call out the apple notes of the porkchop, and the polenta provided a savory herbal note that paired well with both the chop and the tomatoes. It should be noted that past the polenta, we were eating with desire, not hunger. While David spoke of the menu with warning, we gained the impression that most people are dissatisfied that the portions were too small. While this matches up somewhat with impressions gained from other sources online, I cannot imagine someone being hungry after this meal.
We should not have done it, but we saved the remaining portion of porkshop for later and tried the parfait for dessert, although no real room was left in our bellies. The strawberries were prefectly ripe, tender but dense, sweet and tart, nestled in layers of yogurt and whipped cream, dusted with sprinkles of granola. The layers of rich cream, tart yogurt, nutty granola, and sweet/tart berries was uplifting, and if anything served to refresh us. (For those interested, the accompanying coffee was supplied by local roaster intelligentia, and was as good as always. Yes, that's an endorsement.)
While the decor was spare at best, neither was it uneccessarily busy, and in retrospect, it was a perfect environment for the food: simple, and focusing on it's strengths. It didn't speak of luxury, but nor was it cheap. If anything, it was on the postive side of minimalism and honesty in design. They also gain points for not cramming the space to capacity. The food presentation was neither plain nor inspired. Generally, it seemed to service the ingredients more than arcane artistic ideal. Given the seeming theme of this restaurant, that is however appropriate. I would say that 4 points out of five is appropriate.
The service had a few tiny bumps, but these were as simple as failing to catch David's eye during a slow moment as he rested. It was nothing intentional, and the time spent waiting was minimal. Nonetheless, his knowledge of the menu was at time incomplete. While I sympathize, it did drag the service score down from a four to a more average three out of five.
The food was in every instance delicious, if not inspired. While a certain sacrifice in craft was made to focus so much ont he purity of ingredients and their pairing, it was to exceptional effect. The score here is a minimum of seven points out of ten. That gives a grand point total of fourteen out of twenty, or a three star rating out of four, or 70 percent.
To those who complain about the price, (Our tab for three people was $110 pretip, or about 37 per person,) I would point out that all the ingredients are purcchased as locally as possible, and prepared at the peak of freshness. This doesn't even address the perfection of preparation. While I sympathize with those who are startled by the price, it is entirely in line with the market at this point. (Although I hope to establish a baseline on prices to come up with some sort of "value index.") If you are satisfied with dried pasta and a good sauce, there are certainly cheaper alternative's than Terragusto for you, and some of them are quite delicious. Still, if you love fresher items and are willing to pay the premium, the price doesn't get better than Terragusto...and neither does much else.
